November Market Update: Fed Cuts Rates Again, But Annuity Yields On The Rise

Published November 1, 2019
  • This past Wednesday, the Federal Reserve cut interest rates by 0.25% to a targeted range of 1.50% – 1.75%.
  • The move was widely expected by financial markets and the reaction was muted.
  • This is the third straight rate cut.

On October 30, the Fed cut rates, continuing the downward pattern in short-term interest rates that began earlier this year. At the same time, most insurers raised annuity rates slightly this month. What gives?

 In short, the Fed has an outsized impact on the short-term Treasury yields, but not long-term ones, through its rate-setting capacity (Note: It can influence long-term interest rates through quantitative easing, but that’s a discussion best left for another day).

 Take a look at the three-month trend in the difference between the Fed’s benchmark rate and the 10 Year Treasury and you can see how the relationship has flipped. Since July, the Fed Funds Effective Rate was higher than the 10 Year Treasury, but now it’s lower.

Why are yields on the 10 year Treasury increasing? It’s complicated, but most market participants believe it to be some mix of (1) optimism about a China trade war truce; (2) slightly improving economic data; and (3) changing expectations about future central bank policy.

So the Fed cutting rates at the same time medium and long-term yields are rising has caused the yield curve to resume its “normal” shape – upward sloping (but only slightly). All that talk about the inverted yield curve has subsided for now. And as everyone was saying a few months ago, the inverted yield curve portends recession. So does the fact that it’s no longer upward sloping mean we’re in the clear? No is the short answer. Mohamed El-Erian in a Bloomberg op-ed recently wrote a good piece about why here.

If all this seems quite technical, just remember these three things:

  1. Renewed optimism about the trade war with China and improving economic data has caused medium-term and long-term (think 5, 7, 10, and 30 year) yields on Treasury debt to rise, but the Fed has decided to continue to cut short-term rates. 
  2. The Fed’s rate cut puts pressure on the rates that checking, savings, and CD accounts can offer. Most high-yield savings accounts will cut rates in the coming days as a result of the Fed’s action.
  3. As always, don’t look to the Fed as a short-hand for what will happen with annuity rates. Look instead at the 10 Year Treasury yield.
Matt Carey

Matt Carey

Financial Planning Professional

Matt Carey is the co-founder and CEO of Blueprint Income. He believes in the power of technology to make retirement simpler. Matt is a regular contributor to Forbes.com and has been quoted in both the New York Times and Morningstar.

Related Articles

Annuity Trends

July 2019: 10 Year Treasury Yields Drop Below 2%

It continues to be a wild ride in the financial markets. You’d think that trade war fears and some soft recent macroeconomic data would push markets lower. But that’s not what has happened at all. The stock market had its best first half of the year in recent memory. And bond prices have risen to &hellip; <a href="https://www.blueprintincome.com/resources/annuity-trends/november-market-update-fed-cuts-rates-again-but-annuity-yields-on-the-rise/">Continued</a>

Annuity Basics

Recent Fed Moves and Their Impact on Annuity Pricing

Annuity rates didn’t really budge in August. But given the declines in bond yields, that’s actually a good thing and means that annuity pricing might soon decline. If you’re thinking about making an annuity purchase before the end of the year, now is an attractive time to do it.